|
Post by 5 of Hearts on May 29, 2011 11:51:33 GMT -5
Somewhat. You have a one-shot power but your role will be revealed if you're killed. According to Bill's claim, Colby had a one-shot power but his role wasn't revealed - as you mentioned previously. There's no janitor-type role in the list of possible roles so I have to deduce that Bill is lying. The only other explanation for Colby's reveal showing MaryAnn/Town/Vanilla is that this game is gastard. So you are saying that Colby should of been the one shot role that BILL was before he killed Colby. It's not even a one shot role though. Bill had to find Alice in order to be her, according to the role claim. I understand the point that Colby should of been revealed as bill's old role. I also find it suspicious that no one can counterclaim him or verify or really disprove his claim. The only holes you can find are with the PM and those could of been just errors or oversights in the PM with the MOD.
|
|
|
Post by March Hare on May 29, 2011 12:15:22 GMT -5
Remember when you send in the kill add some extra bits. fluff or something in the PM to give it more meat. That gives the MOD a spare sentence to share.
|
|
|
Post by March Hare on May 29, 2011 12:18:00 GMT -5
too late for that now. can you post your NK PM here ?
|
|
|
Post by 5 of Hearts on May 29, 2011 12:20:19 GMT -5
too late for that now. can you post your NK PM here ? Meaning instead of PMing Sisc?
|
|
|
Post by 5 of Hearts on May 29, 2011 12:25:48 GMT -5
too late for that now. can you post your NK PM here ? I have not sent the kill PM. Just the fluff PMs.
|
|
|
Post by SisterCoyote on May 29, 2011 12:26:11 GMT -5
Night actions must be sent via PM, to answer that question. However, it would be useful to me if you could indicate which of those 20 PMs shows the actual Night Kill if it's been sent. Please.
With regard to flips: With one unique exception, all flips will indicate role and alignment as assigned.
|
|
|
Post by 5 of Hearts on May 29, 2011 12:30:33 GMT -5
Night actions must be sent via PM, to answer that question. However, it would be useful to me if you could indicate which of those 20 PMs shows the actual Night Kill if it's been sent. Please.
With regard to flips: With one unique exception, all flips will indicate role and alignment as assigned. None of those have the Night Actions that I am suppose to send. I will send it to you later when we figure out who we want to get rid of.
|
|
|
Post by March Hare on May 29, 2011 12:42:28 GMT -5
too late for that now. can you post your NK PM here ? Meaning instead of PMing Sisc? No just to share how you were wording it
|
|
|
Post by 8ofhearts on May 29, 2011 13:42:40 GMT -5
The main thing is his decision to try with Colby Night 2 after he received the Night 1 result that he couldn't find him. If I had that role, I'm pretty sure I'd try with someone else Night 2. The role PM says: "If you have found Alice, she dies, and you take her place. If you have not found Alice, there will be no effect on that player." Colby didn't die so why not move on?
The rules say there'll be no recruitment but a 3rd party was (passively) recruited to the Town team.
Mary Ann's PM said the role was "Stalker". All other revealed roles were in the list of possible roles, Stalker wasn't.
His role had "Serial Killer/Survivor" in brackets after "Stalker". I wouldn't consider a player who can only kill one specific player a SK. A player who survives till end game but doesn't win isn't a survivor.
Alice's PM doesn't say what her role is, just "You are Town".
The quote used to activate the block of NKs is inaccurate.
He claimed he still had the strongman power but if that was related to Alice, how did Colby die? The wording in the PM indicates it was Mary Ann's power.
He claimed to receive a PM from Sister saying "unless there is a Day Killer..." but hasn't posted it.
I can totally see Alice being a PFK in Wonderland mafia.
I've had a PFK role which investigated as Town.
As PFK, I've always tried to hunt scum just as if I was another Townie.
It just seems wrong that someone can kill Alice, take her place, and not be a threat to Town.
Colby's flip doesn't correspond to Mary Ann's role or alignment.
Is there a case here?
On preview, I see that there's no case here... "One unique exception" is enough for the claim to be feasible despite the other doubts.
|
|
|
Post by March Hare on May 29, 2011 14:09:55 GMT -5
You see why Bill's role is making me crazy
I think I may have hit a nerve with my observations and that has something to do with his "attack?" of me?
|
|
|
Post by 5 of Hearts on May 29, 2011 15:37:26 GMT -5
OK, who are we sending. SP, Bill, or CIAS?
|
|
|
Post by 8ofhearts on May 29, 2011 16:40:00 GMT -5
I'm not inspired toNight, sorry. I've read through Rysto, Story, CIAS, Gnarly and Ma'at's posts and none of them are screaming "I'm the Doc" at me... Gnarly is hinting that he's a politician, CIAS is hinting Vanilla, Rysto is hinting "don't look at me, I wasn't here", Ma'at is doing pretty well for a sub, on Day 3 #174 Story made the same deduction about the N1 lack of kills - deducing Bill was protected and is therefore Town (and Special breadcrumbed it), it's slightly stronger than CIAS but still not worth risking a VT (who seems to think Ginger and I are both Town) compared to the double-but-possibly-triple whammy Suburban offers.
Let's kill Suburban, if you don't want to do it, send "March Hare" as the killer and avoid stating Lightfoot's name (if allowed!)
Good luck!
|
|
|
Post by 8ofhearts on May 29, 2011 17:24:23 GMT -5
In that post, D3#174, Story says "And I'll go a step further, because frankly I'm insanely swamped at work and so I might as well just toss my cards on the table on the rare occassions that I get the chance: I think Bill is probably Town." - breadcrumb of VT?
|
|
|
Post by 5 of Hearts on May 29, 2011 17:42:51 GMT -5
Here is what I PM'd SisC.
******************************************************
Hope you are having a good weekend!
I miss the West Coast!
You write one hell of a game.
I am going to protect Mhaye
Moley should really not be so nosey!
Bill is being fishy.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I am sending myself to kill Suburban Plankton
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I am going to protect BillMc
Have a wonderful rest of your weekend!
|
|
|
Post by 5 of Hearts on May 29, 2011 17:47:18 GMT -5
Hope we are all alive when day breaks!
|
|